Translate

Showing posts with label investigation. Show all posts
Showing posts with label investigation. Show all posts

Tuesday, November 26, 2013

Facts, not beliefs should be the basis of any investigation

Since last several days I have been keeping the track of all the videos, articles, reports, trolls about Tarun Tejpal molesting a female colleague. I have also been keeping track about the most sensationalized Aarushi Talwar murder case, and in both of the cases, the ideas exchanged, the discussions of the possible situations, outcomes, the statements made, and the real or the made-up stories surrounding them has amazed me.
Look at, how judgemental we human beings are. We do not care about any proofs and evidences; all we concentrate on is our beliefs. There is an immense difference between facts and beliefs, and we fail to understand that difference again and again.

In his statement, I read on Firstpost, Tarun Tejpal alleged that the incident was 'only light-hearted bantering which led to a moment of privacy’ and the victim, post the incident, was out late into the night attending parties and social gatherings.' No matter what the real story is, who is right and who is wrong, the statement is so contradictory. The man, accepts the fact that it was a ‘light-hearted bantering’, which as the tone suggests is very normal for the educated and open people should be and yet what follows is ‘she was late out into the night attending parties and social gatherings’, so what? Someone is disturbed, is out in a professional event, does not have the time to sit and think what someone she respects has done to her, what is the harm in going and partying?

Why we are so entangles in our beliefs, in the rules we have made for ourselves. Why is being disturbed and sad attached to sitting alone, or getting angry or creating a scene? Why can’t someone who is molested, have no expression of insult, scare or anger on her face?

Every girl gets molested at least once in her life, in the hands of someone she knows, how many cases like that have been reported? I was 14 when I was molested by a family member, he caressed by breasts, which had just started to grow. I got up from there and kept and sat besides my mom, and wouldn't leave her hand till we are out of that place. I was still smiling, playing and talking normally to my mom and everyone around; include that person who tried molesting me. I expressed my discomfort only after years, when my family planned to go to their place again, and the plan was cancelled after hearing what the man of the family had done to me.

Before you make statements, or thrust the rules you have made in your own mind on others, come to terms with the reality, with the fact that a women is not always weak, that a women can show no emotions and yet fight for her rights. Every person is different and has his/her own way of dealing with things, and in the eyes of law, facts and only facts are valid, not any belief of self-made conclusions.

Thursday, October 17, 2013

The Aarushi-Hemraj Murder Case - A view

Came across a detailed investigation in Tehelka yesterday morning, Have read it thrice already since yesterday. I don’t know how true it is, but as long as Tehelka’s reputation goes, they won’t print anything so serious, with so much confidence in their words. Till last year even I believed the media reports that said ‘The Double murder’ was a honor killing,  but recently, few months back, after reading a lot of reports on honor killings and the rapes around the city, it is a little difficult to believe the honor killing motive linked with the double murder.
As the Tehelka report goes, there are absolutely 0 evidences against the Talwars, and substantially evidence against the aides. I somehow come to believe this, even if I sound biased or irrational, I don’t see the point of killing their only daughter because she was on the bed with their house helper. Firstly, as many such cases I have heard about, the abuse/bad behavior/torture from the side of the family in such cases happens over a period of time before the actual action (killing), but here as per the reports, the Talwar family looked a happy family, with none of Aarushi’s family, friends or even her school’s staff complained of she being depressed or any negative change in the behavior. I don’t believe the fact that a father will get up, pick up a golf club, enter his daughter’s room, just because he heard some noise, and not even think once before hitting her on the head. And even if it did happen, is this one of the evidence the CBI is fighting the case on?
Secondly, After suffering mentally, physically, financially for almost 2-3 years after their daughter’s death, being blamed as the murderers of their only daughter, being almost convicted, no person will want the case to reopen, simply, because if they were really the murderers they would have dreaded conviction, and would have relieved after the CBI closed the case, declared no evidence against Talwars. If the Parents hated their daughter so much, that they killed her, wouldn’t they just get back to their normal lives after the case being declared closed.
Thirdly, the report mentions that the sequence of the crime could possibly be this (confessed by the aides in the narco and other tests) The aides gathered in Hemraj’s room, consumed alcohol, discussed Aarushi, entered Aarushi’s room, and probably tried getting close to her, and her refusal made them hit her. Well, isn’t this believable? Haven’t we heard about all the gang rapes happening around? The fact that they had consumed alcohol only makes a little more believable.
I don’t know if the report is completely true, but read it once, and you will be left with so many questions, and absolutely no trust in the Indian Judicial system, The police and The CBI.